The BDN Editorial Board operates independently from the newsroom, and doesn’t set insurance policies or contribute to reporting or modifying articles elsewhere within the newspaper or on bangordailynews.com.
State officers should proceed to establish and handle issues in Maine’s baby welfare system to higher defend youngsters and households.
The reality is that heartbreaking, infuriating failures have occurred on this system below each Republican and Democratic administrations for many years. We’re assured in saying, regardless of some differing opinions about what to do about it, that officers throughout the political spectrum all need to forestall future tragedies.
That recognition should be entrance and heart because the Legislature’s Authorities Oversight Committee will get set to satisfy Wednesday and focus on potential subsequent steps in a disagreement with the administration of Gov. Janet Mills over entry to sure baby protecting case information. The committee has sought the information from 4 current baby deaths with mother and father accused of killing their youngsters. The Maine Division of Well being and Human Providers has denied that request, pointing to confidentiality points and the chance of jeopardizing ongoing prosecutions.
The denial facilities round recommendation offered by the Maine legal professional normal’s workplace in June, which mentioned that DHHS couldn’t share the confidential case information instantly with the oversight committee however that they may very well be launched to the Workplace of Program Analysis and Authorities Accountability, which the committee directs. OPEGA workers may then analyze and current data to the committee in a manner that preserves confidentiality. The same course of has been utilized in different baby demise circumstances, earlier than prosecution concluded.
Oversight committee members should now resolve whether or not to flex their subpoena energy and proceed to hunt the complete case information. As some members have acknowledged, that may seemingly take up money and time in court docket.
If committee members consider they aren’t being granted entry to paperwork and knowledge they’re legally entitled to of their oversight position, then this could not be an unreasonable path to say legislative energy as a coequal department of presidency. Clarifying the authorities and limits below current statute could be an vital willpower for this and different oversight issues. However that could be a considerably philosophical train in contrast with the extra speedy want of studying from previous failures and stopping future baby deaths.
From a sensible standpoint, we preserve going again to the recommendation from Assistant Legal professional Normal Ariel Gannon, and the truth that three months have now passed by because it was offered. Gannon suggested DHHS to work with OPEGA “to outline the data OPEGA wants to satisfy its directive from GOC; that DHHS and OPEGA negotiate and agree upon phrases of disclosure and preservation of confidentiality; and that DHHS adjust to OPEGA’s request for confidential protecting data and data below these phrases.”
The committee ought to start that course of, and start it this week. They need to even have a dialog about whether or not it’s attainable to subpoena the complete case information on the similar time. We’re not satisfied that one would preclude the opposite, however we’ll go away that query to the legal professionals.
From our place on the sidelines, given the present authorized opinions and timing realities with only some months left earlier than a brand new Legislature is sworn in, it appears to us that shifting ahead with the method outlined within the assistant legal professional normal’s letter — which DHHS mentioned in August they “stand prepared” to interact in — is the most efficient path ahead within the quick time period with a view to steadiness the oversight committee’s position, confidentiality and the integrity of ongoing prosecutions.
True justice for these baby victims, we consider, should go additional than convicting the people who’re instantly accountable. It should additionally embrace ongoing work (and this is only one piece of it) to pinpoint and repair systemic points which will have contributed to those tragedies.
For lawmakers to proceed that work, they want entry to as a lot data as attainable, as quickly as attainable. The legal professional normal’s workplace advised a strategy to obtain this in June, and at a minimal, it’s previous time for the oversight committee, OPEGA and DHHS to stroll that path collectively.