I used to be born in 1965, the final of Mum and Dad’s brood of kids. Years earlier than, my brother Stephen had died in an accident within the kitchen of our dwelling. Though his loss of life was by no means mentioned, he was additionally by no means forgotten.
“You’re considered one of 11,” Mum would appropriate me every time I did not acknowledge the sibling I’d by no means met. “You’ve 4 sisters and 6 brothers.”
It appeared a finicky element for a girl who’d failed to recollect my appropriate date of beginning for the primary dozen years of my life, an error that was solely rectified after checking my beginning certificates upfront of my affirmation. The truth that the date change (from February 19 to 21) additionally modified my star signal (from Aquarius to Pisces) was, apparently, inconsequential, Mum sustaining I used to be simply fortunate (in contrast to Stephen, presumably) to have a birthday to rejoice.
So sure, Stephen all the time counted in our family tally. However because it seems, my birthday wasn’t the one household element Mum had did not precisely recall. What do they are saying about hindsight being 20/20? This was actually true for me 18 months in the past as I started recording a podcast about different folks’s weird household tales.
As a part of the venture, I started documenting my very own. Telephoning my siblings one after the other, I recorded the tales I’d grown up listening to: Dad swindling his employer and dropping firm cash on the racetrack; Michael being shot at in Goondiwindi by a gun-toting neighbour as he retrieved a stray cricket ball; Damian, the second-youngest, born prematurely, being positioned within the fridge to chill him from the blistering Queensland summer time.
However together with the various amusing tales I heard retold, there have been additionally tales of hardship and sorrow, most notably the loss of life of Stephen one early-autumn day in 1951. Since Mum and Dad hardly ever spoke of the tragedy, the main points my 9 elder siblings shared have been scant however constant.
On the time of Stephen’s accident, Mum was within the yard of the household dwelling at Cringila, a suburb of Wollongong. Whereas unsupervised within the kitchen, Stephen pulled the twine hooked up to a kettle, pouring boiling water over himself. He died later that evening in hospital. However there was one key element new to me: Stephen’s accident occurred when he was simply seven months outdated, whereas he was nonetheless in his bassinet.
Within the Seventies, on the one event once I’d had the adolescent insensitivity to ask Mum concerning the accident, she had led me to consider Stephen was two when he died. Granted, Mum wasn’t a stickler for beginning dates, however this anomaly struck me as greater than an administrative error. It felt like a deception. However why?
I went into full Poirot mode to uncover the reality. And though “Dying in Cringila” didn’t have fairly the identical je ne sais quoi as Homicide on the Orient Categorical, it turned each bit the page-turner.
My expertise as a podcaster, listening to others inform their tales of household dysfunction, had taught me a few essential classes: one, by no means request a DNA check except you’re ready to just accept your cousin as your father, and two, household secrets and techniques are all the time began to guard somebody. Mum had led me to the belief that Stephen was a toddler to make the circumstances of his loss of life extra plausible: she had needed to close down the dialog and keep away from any follow-up questions.
However her revisionist model of occasions didn’t make sense. It didn’t exonerate her, so who was it designed to guard?
The author’s mom on her eightieth birthday. She took the main points of her son Stephen’s passing to her grave.Credit score:Courtesy of Paul Dunne
On the time Mum was so deftly deflecting my line of questioning, Agatha Christie was my favorite writer. Now, 40 years later, I went into full Poirot mode to uncover the reality. And though “Dying in Cringila” didn’t have fairly the identical je ne sais quoi as Homicide on the Orient Categorical, it turned each bit the page-turner as I spent hours scouring digitised copies of The Illawarra Mercury for clues.
However an excellent sleuth with forensic focus I’m not, and there have been crimson herrings aplenty within the papers of the day. Among the many folksy ads for “NEW!” Neapolitan ice-cream and bus journeys to the Sutherland Shire, I discovered
myself always sidetracked by tales of communists and the Nation Ladies’s Affiliation – though, sadly, by no means in the identical article.
Loading
The headline “Child Fatally Scalded” from Wednesday, April 11, 1951 jolted me again to actuality. The brief, front-page merchandise confirmed my brother’s age, however gave no clue as to Mum’s later distortion. Nevertheless, my obsession with the Menzies-era Mercury had revealed that the coroner’s court docket reporter was an everyday contributor.
So I continued my search till the inevitable follow-up piece appeared on June 1. Studying the article, “Child’s Dying Due To Shock After Scalding” was like witnessing a collision – the purpose the place one model of historical past ricochets off one other. “Anthony,” it learn, “had inadvertently pushed the bassinet nearer the bench and the child had caught maintain of the twine of the kettle.”
My Poirot second had arrived. Anthony, my second-eldest and maybe most-loved brother, had performed a hand within the loss of life of our child sibling. Being solely 4 on the time, he had no recollection of the occasion and, naturally, no blame had ever been attributed to him.
One of many newspaper articles from 1951 that helped Dunne uncover the reality.Credit score:Courtesy of Paul Dunne
Mum blamed nobody however herself, and her testimony, so dispassionately cited within the newspaper article, will need to have been a brutal underscore to the trauma she’d already endured. It was no surprise she hid these particulars to her loss of life in 2006, aged 82; silence may by no means carry Stephen again, however it may defend the opposite harmless sufferer.
However uncovering such a carefully guarded secret introduced with it a burden I’d naively did not anticipate: now that I knew, what was I to do with the data?
“Hey, when you’d by chance killed your brother, would you need to be informed?” I didn’t know the way I may ever presumably ask this query with out revealing my hand and depriving Anthony of the selection. However after weeks of contemplation, I made a decision a household reunion was the very best place to start out.
Now household gatherings usually are not our factor. Our final had been held in Ballina, in northern NSW, over Christmas in 1974. Coincidentally, it was the identical time Cyclone Tracy hit Darwin, and the jury’s out on which occasion was extra catastrophic. However time had eroded most of the sharp edges from numerous relationships and, the place as soon as our household comprised extra factions than the ALP, we have been now extra akin to a semi-functioning coalition.
Exploiting the mellowness, I made my proposal: let’s collect for a siblings-only weekend in Goondiwindi, the one place the place we had all as soon as lived. Virtually instantly, the RSVPs got here flooding in and a date was agreed: Might 2021. A sizeable Airbnb was booked and the Dunne clan descended on the unsuspecting outback city on the Queensland/NSW border.
Time had eroded most of the sharp edges from numerous relationships and, the place as soon as our household comprised extra factions than the ALP, we have been now extra akin to a semi-functioning coalition.
In readiness, I’d set an itinerary designed to stoke recollections and provoke dialog, with a trivia quiz after dinner on Friday setting the tone. Passing round a tin of ready questions on our childhood adventures – and no, “Guess who killed Stephen?” wasn’t considered one of them – we have been all quickly revelling in nostalgia, our present-day selves all however forgotten. We have been simply youngsters as soon as once more, gathered across the household desk.
The Dunne siblings reunited, together with Paul (centre), and Anthony subsequent to him (proper).Credit score:Courtesy of Paul Dunne
We spent Saturday on the Gunsynd Park racetrack for Dad, Sunday morning at
St Mary’s Church for Mum. We have been handled to a guided tour of St Mary’s Main College, visited our outdated household dwelling, and positioned a plaque (guerrilla-style) on the Goondiwindi Memorial Pool, renaming it after our father who had carried out unlawful playing nights to boost funds for its development within the Nineteen Sixties.
By Sunday evening, we had recounted each hilarious household fable from 1945 to 1980, and the subjects grew extra sombre. Lastly, over a roast-pork dinner that might have been conjured by our lifeless mom, I had the chance to unobtrusively elevate the topic of Stephen’s loss of life and the silence surrounding it. After which, virtually as if on cue, Anthony questioned aloud if he’d had something to do with our brother’s accident.
“Would you need to know when you had?” I requested, seemingly with out intent. Right here I used to be, lastly posing the query I’d orchestrated this elaborate tour simply to ask. In my creativeness, this was Anthony’s second to show a furrowed forehead and contemplative chin-stroke.
However his response was instant and decisive. “Wouldn’t make any distinction,” he mentioned. “I used to be 4 years outdated.”
Loading
Had I been an neutral therapist, I feel I’d have been happy with how he’d processed the likelihood. However I used to be his brother who’d positioned nice emphasis on this second. Wouldn’t it kill him to feign a little bit of soul-searching? I’d by no means supposed to inform Anthony over the weekend what I’d found however, proper then, I used to be tempted to deal with him to a dinnertime denouement.
However then one thing else occurred I’d by no means anticipated. Because of the blissful time we’d all shared, Anthony’s response to the Large Query wasn’t a lot anticlimactic as irrelevant. The circumstances of Stephen’s loss of life, taken by our mother and father to their graves, immediately appeared superfluous. Removed from a reunion to redefine the previous, our gathering had morphed into one thing extra significant. It had served to remind us vividly of the enjoyment that had dominated our childhoods and helped us create a brand new reminiscence so as to add to the household mythology, many years after the final recollections have been made.
The plains of western Queensland are flat and infinite, with a grand cinematic scope. Driving out of Goondiwindi the next day, the credit rolling via my thoughts, I considered the recorded conversations that had been the prelude to this stunning journey. And it struck me: the voice I hadn’t heard, couldn’t have heard, had by no means heard, was finally the loudest. Stephen, our misplaced sibling, had all the time been a presence in our household life.
And 70 years after his loss of life, he’d introduced his brothers and sisters again collectively. It was true what Mum had mentioned. I’m considered one of 11.
Postscript: Final October, with the border closure making it unattainable for me to journey from Sydney to Anthony’s dwelling in Queensland, I phoned my brother to inform him what I’d uncovered about his previous. Ever sensible, Anthony’s first response was bemusement that I’d gone to a lot bother to navigate the dilemma. Then he mirrored on what Mum had mentioned to him, close to delirium in her hospital mattress, shortly earlier than she died. “Don’t consider something you examine Stephen,” she had informed him, seeking to defend him till her final breath. Having inherited the household secret, I appreciated the burden it will need to have positioned on her for all these years. But it surely additionally confirmed for me a better reality: secrets and techniques typically reveal extra concerning the individuals who preserve them than these they’re supposedly about.
To learn extra from Good Weekend journal, go to our web page at The Sydney Morning Herald, The Age and Brisbane Occasions.
The perfect of Good Weekend delivered to your inbox each Saturday morning. Enroll right here.
