Military police watchdog slams new policy on sexual assualt

Article content material

OTTAWA — The army’s police watchdog is lambasting the pressure for leaving it as much as victims of sexual assault to resolve whether or not to have their criticism transferred to civilian authorities, a coverage that flies within the face of reforms known as for by former justice Louise Arbour and totally adopted by the Liberal authorities.

In a scathing resolution dated Feb. 6 and obtained through an entry to info request, Navy Police Grievance Fee chairperson Tammy Tremblay says the police pressure has put in place a “troubling coverage” that places an “unfair burden” on victims of sexual misconduct.

Article content material

Article content material

The army police are transferring legal offences of a sexual nature to civilian police businesses in Ontario, however according to Tremblay, officers are first asking the sufferer’s permission.

The coverage defies a suggestion by Justice Louise Arbour, who printed a damning report in 2022 on sexual misconduct within the army that known as for a whole overhaul of the system.

Arbour advisable that each one intercourse crime investigations and prosecutions be pulled out of the arms of army police, prosecutors and judges and despatched to the civilian system with out asking for the sufferer’s desire.

“For my part, requiring the sufferer’s consent earlier than deciding whether or not to research or prosecute against the law within the army or civilian justice system merely places an unrealistic burden on the sufferer,” she wrote, including it put the sufferer in an “untenable place” that will depart them without end second-guessing their resolution.

The brand new coverage additionally contradicts Defence Minister Invoice Blair’s personal calls for for his division and the Canadian Armed Forces.

When Arbour printed her 2021 interim report and 2022 full report — which constructed on a separate evaluate by Justice Maurice Fish in 2021 — the Liberal authorities dedicated to implement all of her suggestions.

Article content material

Article content material

In a press release Friday, Blair’s spokesperson, Diana Ebadi, mentioned that “the present interim measures which place the burden on the sufferer to decide on between methods are unrealistic and never within the public curiosity.”

“Madame Arbour due to this fact advisable that each one Legal Code sexual offences must be investigated and prosecuted solely within the civilian system, and Minister Blair agrees with this in full,” she added.

Michel Drapeau, a army regulation skilled who ceaselessly represents army victims of sexual crimes, says Tremblay’s letter exhibits that the army is strolling again on its dedication to implement Arbour’s suggestions.

He mentioned his emotions have advanced from “disenchanted” and “pissed off” to “disillusioned” as he known as on the minister to alter the regulation in order that army police and prosecutors now not have the jurisdiction to research intercourse crimes in Canada.

That’s precisely what the federal government will do when it tables new laws “within the coming weeks,” Blair’s spokesperson mentioned Friday.

In her resolution addressed to the Canadian Forces Provost Marshall, Tremblay laid out her incomprehension over the very fact the up to date army police coverage commits to implement Arbour’s suggestions all of the whereas implementing modifications that go in opposition to them.

Article content material

“It’s puzzling that the CFPM references Madame Arbour’s suggestion in his coverage, whereas implementing instructions that contradict it,” she wrote.

“For my part, in its present iteration, this coverage doesn’t meet the victim-centric, trauma-informed threshold, and in reality, simply as Madame Arbour cautioned, places an unfair burden on victims,” she mentioned.

In a press release, CFPM spokesperson Lt.-Cmdr. Jamie Bresolin mentioned the workplace has transferred to the civilian system about one-third (103) of the 285 new sexual offence instances reported to army police since Arbour’s interim report in late 2021.

Bresolin additionally confirmed that CFPM asks victims whether or not they desire their case to be investigated by the civilian or army police.

Of the instances that remained with the army justice system, 135 had been by no means referred to civilian police, typically as a result of “the sufferer’s views” had been thought-about, Bresolin added.

Civilian police refused to take the remaining 46, which suggests they stayed with army police.

One switch request is pending.

Article content material

Tremblay’s resolution says that her workplace was set to launch an investigation right into a criticism that the army police was ignoring a directive by former defence minister Anita Anand and her successor, Blair, to switch sexual misconduct instances to the civilian justice system.

However she needed to pull the plug on the investigation when she obtained a letter from Blair’s workplace in late January that neither he nor Anand had ever issued such a directive.

“Neither I nor my predecessor have issued any such path to the CFPM. Nor has both of us directed the Chief of the Defence Employees to concern such path,” reads an excerpt of the response despatched to Tremblay by Blair’s workplace in January and quoted in her resolution.

The defence minister’s spokesperson confirmed that neither minister issued a directive. Quite, one was issued from the heads of the army police and army prosecution service to their very own workers “following Madame Arbour’s October 2021 interim suggestion to switch instances.”

Each Drapeau and Dalhousie College regulation professor Elaine Craig say they’re “completely confounded” by Blair’s letter to the MPCC as a result of the minister had clearly issued a directive to his division by totally accepting Arbour’s suggestion.

Article content material

“Minister Anand was very clear, repeatedly, that she accepted all of Madame Arbour’s suggestions, together with the advice that sexual offence instances involving CAF members must be investigated by civilian police forces,” she mentioned by e mail.

“It’s equally clear that the CAF has been directed to maneuver these investigations to civilian police.”

Division of Nationwide Defence spokesperson Andrée-Anne Poulin mentioned “intensive” efforts to switch investigations to civilian authorities are underway, however it’s a complicated endeavour.

“Our main concern stays the assist to the sufferer, due to this fact Navy Police coordination with the civilian police of concurrent jurisdiction is completed in a deliberate method, making each effort to reduce the influence on the sufferer,” she wrote in a press release.

Arbour and Fish declined to touch upon Tremblay’s resolution.

Our web site is the place for the newest breaking information, unique scoops, longreads and provocative commentary. Please bookmark nationalpost.com and join our politics e-newsletter, First Studying, right here.

Article content material